Which natural cane reed should you choose for your clarinet? A comparison of Vandoren, D’Addario, Gonzalez and Marca

Choosing the right reed is essential for achieving a beautiful tone, precise articulation, and comfortable playing on the clarinet. Yet, with so many brands and different ranges available, it is not always easy to know where to start.

Should you choose Vandoren, D'Addario, Gonzalez, or Marca? Are some models better suited to beginners, orchestral musicians, or jazz clarinetists?

Each manufacturer offers reeds with their own cut, thickness, and response characteristics.

In this article, we compare the main ranges for B-flat clarinet, primarily Boehm system, and offer advice on finding the ones that best suit your playing.

1. Vandoren: the leading French brand

Founded in 1905 by Eugène Van Doren, Vandoren is one of the oldest manufacturers of reeds and mouthpieces for wind instruments.

Internationally renowned, it offers several ranges of natural cane reeds, each with its own design.

Traditional reeds: versatility and balance

What sets them apart: The Traditional reed is a versatile standard, aiming for a balance between attack response, articulation, and tonal richness. It serves as a practical point of comparison before trying more specialized cuts.

Easily recognizable by their blue box, Traditional reeds are used by many clarinetists, from students to professionals.

They offer a pleasing balance of articulation, response, and tonal richness.

Their versatility makes them suitable for a variety of repertoires, including classical music, wind band music, chamber music, and contemporary music.

Who are they for? Beginners, amateur players, and professionals looking for a versatile reed.

V12 reeds: tonal richness and depth

What sets them apart: Their thicker tip and heel, as well as their longer vibrating area, distinguish them from the Traditional reed. This design aims for a richer, deeper tone, with levels of resistance that should be checked with your mouthpiece.

V12 reeds are made from larger-diameter cane. Their tip and heel are thicker than those of the Traditional reeds, while their vibrating area is longer.

This design promotes a rich, deep tone with a fuller attack.

They may appeal to musicians looking for a wide range of tonal nuances, particularly in classical and orchestral repertoire.

Who are they for? Clarinetists wishing to explore a rich, deep tone.

56 rue Lepic reeds: stability and precision

What sets them apart: Their uniquely designed heel, similar to some German cuts, sets them apart. Vandoren highlights their centered tone, stability, and evenness across registers.

This range is named after Vandoren's historic address in Paris.

They feature a unique design, notably with a heel similar to that of German-cut reeds.

According to the manufacturer, they produce a rich, centered, and pure tone, with excellent stability and immediate response across the different registers.

Who are they for? Musicians who prefer a centered tone and even sound production.

V21 reeds: projection and flexibility

What sets them apart: The V21 combines the cut of the V12 with the shape of the 56 rue Lepic. This combination aims to balance tonal richness, projection, and responsiveness, particularly during register changes.

V21 reeds combine the cut of the V12 with the shape of the 56 rue Lepic.

This combination aims to provide a warm, deep tone while promoting immediate vibration and good projection.

They are particularly useful in passages involving rapid register changes.

Who are they for? Musicians looking for a balance of tonal richness, projection, and responsiveness.

Vandoren strength comparison chart

For example, the following ratings refer to reeds for B-flat clarinet and use the Traditional reed as a reference. The comparisons remain theoretical and do not guarantee equivalent playing sensations.

Vandoren Traditional V12 V21 56 rue Lepic
3.5 Approximately 3.5 3.5+ Approximately 3.5+

Ratings taken from Vandoren's technical specifications and the D'Addario interbrand chart. See the complete chart for the other strengths.

2. D'Addario: ranges suited to different skill levels

A well-known American manufacturer in the music world, D'Addario offers reeds from the historic Rico brand, among others.

Its catalog supports clarinetists from their first notes through to advanced playing.

Rico: accessible sound production

What sets them apart: Rico reeds feature an unfiled cut, with a relatively thin blank and profile. This design is intended to make them easier to vibrate and control, particularly during the first years of learning. On the same mouthpiece, it is useful to compare their attack and support with those of the Royal, without assuming that two reeds with the same strength rating will respond identically.

Rico reeds are often recommended for starting out on the clarinet.

Their design provides a relatively accessible response, allowing students to focus on their breathing, embouchure, and learning the notes.

Who are they for? Beginners and young clarinetists.

Royal: a balance of flexibility and control

What sets them apart: Unlike the Rico, the Royal has a filed French cut, recognizable by the area of bark removed beneath the cut section. D'Addario combines this profile with greater tonal clarity while maintaining a traditional blank and an accessible response. To distinguish Rico from Royal, test their staccato, soft attacks, and evenness across registers.

Royal reeds are another option for developing musicians.

They aim for an easy response, precise articulation, and balanced tone.

They allow you to explore more nuances while maintaining an accessible feel.

Who are they for? Developing students and amateur players.

Reserve: richness and expressiveness

What sets them apart: Reserve reeds feature a filed cut and a more elaborate profile than the Rico and Royal series, with cane distribution designed for control over tone color and nuances. They should be evaluated on the evenness of their pianissimo, articulation, and transition between the chalumeau and clarion registers. They are not necessarily better suited to all musicians: the mouthpiece opening and chosen strength remain decisive factors.

Reserve reeds have a more elaborate design, intended for musicians seeking a rich tone and greater expressive possibilities.

They aim to provide good flexibility in nuances and a controlled response.

Who are they for? Advanced and professional clarinetists.

Reserve Evolution: another approach to projection

What sets them apart: D'Addario describes the Reserve Evolution as the range with the thickest blank in its Reserve family; its cut is unfiled. This construction aims particularly at projection, stability, and flexibility in nuances. A greater amount of material does not automatically mean a harder reed: compare playing comfort and support rather than the strength rating alone.

Reserve Evolution reeds are designed to provide a full tone, good projection, and significant expressive possibilities.

They may appeal to clarinetists wishing to compare different sensations of resistance and vibration.

Who are they for? Experienced musicians looking for a specific tonal response.

D'Addario strength comparison chart

Example of how to read the official D'Addario comparison, using a Vandoren Traditional 3 as a starting point. The positions correspond to indicative resistance levels, not to an identical tone or response.

Reference Rico Royal Reserve Reserve Evolution
Vandoren Traditional 3 Approximately 3.5 Approximately 3.5 Approximately 3 Approximately 3

Source: official D'Addario strength comparison chart, including competing ranges. The other strengths can be viewed on the complete chart.

3. Gonzalez: Argentine reeds to discover

The Gonzalez brand is based in Argentina, in the Mendoza region.

It grows and processes the natural cane used for its wind instrument reeds.

Less known to some French clarinetists, it nevertheless offers a variety of ranges with distinctly different cut characteristics.

Gonzalez Classic: a traditional cut

What sets them apart: The Classic features a traditional French cut and provides a reference for discovering the other Gonzalez profiles. It allows you to compare the sensation of resistance and the balance of response with the RC, FOF, and GD ranges.

Classic reeds feature a traditional French cut.

They offer a balanced response and can be a good starting point for discovering Gonzalez reeds.

Who are they for? Musicians looking for sensations similar to traditional French reeds.

Gonzalez RC: flexibility and responsiveness

What sets them apart: Gonzalez presents the RC as more flexible than the Classic, with easier sound production. Its quarter-strength graduations allow for finer adjustment of the perceived resistance.

According to the manufacturer, RC reeds feature cut modifications that make them more flexible and easier to play than the Classic.

Their quarter-strength graduations also make it easier to choose the right one.

Who are they for? Clarinetists who prefer flexibility and a spontaneous response.

Gonzalez FOF: free vibration

What sets them apart: According to Gonzalez, the FOF prioritizes free vibration and tonal richness, particularly noticeable in the lower register. It should be compared to the Classic and RC on the same mouthpiece.

FOF stands for For Our Friends.

This range resulted from work with clarinetists seeking specific characteristics.

It features a profile that promotes free vibration and good tonal richness, particularly in the lower register.

Who are they for? Musicians wishing to explore a different vibration sensation and a deep tone.

Gonzalez GD: depth and fullness

What sets them apart: The use of larger-diameter cane and a different distribution of material aims for a full vibration and a deep tone. The sensation of support also depends on the chosen strength.

GD reeds are made from larger-diameter cane, with a design that leaves more material in certain areas.

They aim for a deep tone and full vibration.

Who are they for? Experienced clarinetists wishing to try a reed that offers a different sensation of support.

Gonzalez strength comparison chart

The Classic, RC, FOF, and GD series should not be compared based solely on the number indicated on the box. Gonzalez publishes an official strength comparison chart, which compares its models with other brands.

Due to a lack of sufficiently verified numerical values for all ranges, no numerical equivalencies are invented here.

4. Marca: French cane expertise

Based in Provence, Marca makes clarinet reeds from natural cane. It deserves its place alongside the best-known brands: as with other manufacturers, differences in cut, strength, and sensation should be evaluated with your own mouthpiece.

Marca Supérieure: a traditional approach

What sets them apart: the Supérieure is Marca's standard natural cane range. For the B-flat clarinet, it allows you to discover the brand's sensations in a traditional cut. The manufacturer highlights control over sound production, evenness, and nuances; these qualities should be evaluated with your usual mouthpiece, particularly during soft attacks.

A natural cane range to try to discover Marca's unique response and sensations.

Who are they for? Students, amateur players, and experienced clarinetists wishing to compare traditional reeds.

Marca Excel: explore a different profile

What sets them apart: according to Marca, the Excel for B-flat clarinet is made from a thick blank. The manufacturer combines this construction with stability, significant projection, and precise articulation, including in fast passages. Compare it to the Supérieure with the same mouthpiece to evaluate the response, nuances, and sensation of resistance.

This range allows you to explore a different design for a cane reed. The sensation of flexibility or resistance depends particularly on the strength and the combination with the mouthpiece.

Who are they for? Clarinetists who want to try a different cut.

Marca Premium: refine your choice

What sets them apart: Premium is a specific Marca range, distinct from Supérieure and Excel. The publicly available technical information does not allow for a certain determination of a systematic difference in thickness, flexibility, or tone compared to these two models. For a rigorous comparison, evaluate attacks, register intonation, tone stability, and nuances on the same mouthpiece; the brand's comparison chart can guide your initial choice.

Another natural cane range from the brand, to be compared with the other models on the same mouthpiece, particularly for ease of sound production, nuances, and articulation.

Who are they for? Musicians wishing to refine their playing sensations.

To discover separately: Marca also offers UNIC hybrid reeds, combining cane and synthetic fibers. They are featured in our article on synthetic and hybrid reeds.

Marca strength comparison chart

The strength of a Marca Supérieure, Excel, or Premium should not be automatically equated with that of another brand. Marca provides an official comparison of its reeds and a reed finder tool.

A numerical comparison will be more useful when it can be confirmed for each range: the comparison between models and the perceived strength are not necessarily identical.

5. Comparison chart of cane reeds for clarinet

Brand Range Main characteristics
Vandoren Traditional Versatility, crisp attacks, and balanced tone
Vandoren V12 Full sound, rich nuances
Vandoren 56 rue Lepic Centered sound, stability and consistency
Vandoren V21 Projection, responsiveness and flexibility
D’Addario Rico Easy response and comfortable articulation
D’Addario Royal Clear articulation, balanced sound
D’Addario Reserve Rich tone, nuanced control
D’Addario Reserve Evolution Full sound, projection and articulation
Gonzalez Classic Balanced sound, more pronounced resistance
Gonzalez RC Easy response, responsiveness
Gonzalez FOF Free vibration, rich lower register
Gonzalez GD Deep sound, fullness and support
Marca Supérieure Clear and stable sound, precise articulation
Marca Excel Powerful and clear sound, clear projection and articulation
Marca Premium Response precision and nuanced control to test

These indications are comparison points, not sound promises. Strengths are not necessarily equivalent from one brand or range to another.

6. How does the mouthpiece affect the choice of reed strength?

The tables above compare reed strengths, but do not prescribe a single strength for each mouthpiece. The opening and table length influence the sensation of resistance. For recommendations specific to the B45, 5RV, M15, BD4 or BD5 models, consult the technical sheets of the mouthpiece manufacturers, especially Vandoren. When changing ranges, test two adjacent strengths with your usual mouthpiece.

To learn more about choosing the right resistance, consult our guide: Which reed strength should I choose for my clarinet?

7. Which reeds should I choose according to my level and repertoire?

For a beginner

The priority is to find a reed that allows you to produce a sound easily, without straining the embouchure.

Vandoren Traditional, D'Addario Rico or Royal reeds are common references. A Marca Supérieure of the appropriate strength can also be tried with the teacher's advice.

The teacher can recommend a strength suited to the mouthpiece and the student's development.

For playing in a wind band

The musician generally seeks a consistent sound, precise articulation and good control of nuances.

Vandoren Traditional, V12, V21 and 56 rue Lepic, D'Addario Reserve, certain Gonzalez or Marca reeds may be interesting.

For classical music

The quality of legato, consistency across registers and richness of nuances are essential.

It may be relevant to try several cuts among the Vandoren V12, 56 rue Lepic and V21, D'Addario Reserve, Gonzalez FOF or GD and different Marca reeds.

For jazz and contemporary music

The choice depends mainly on the desired sound, the mouthpiece and the musician's comfort.

Some reeds may give a sensation of flexibility or resistance better suited to a given style of playing.

However, no brand is exclusively reserved for a musical style.

The choice of a reed also depends on the entire equipment: our article Mouthpiece, reed and ligature: how to find the right combination? details this interaction.

8. How to properly compare several reeds?

To compare different brands, it is important to maintain the same playing conditions as much as possible.

Start by using the same instrument and the same mouthpiece.

Then try the reeds with identical exercises:

  • A long note in the lower register.
  • A scale covering the different registers.
  • Detached attacks.
  • A fast passage.
  • An expressive musical passage with several nuances.

Evaluate the ease of response, articulation, tonal richness and overall comfort.

It is also advisable to rotate several cane reeds, rather than systematically playing on the same one.

Another essential point is the positioning of the reed on the mouthpiece.

A slightly off-center reed or one placed at a different height can change its response. This can make the comparison less reliable.

9. Why is the positioning of the reed as important as its choice?

When a clarinetist changes reeds, they change the cut, thickness or strength, but they can also, without realizing it, slightly move the reed on the mouthpiece. A different positioning can influence the response and playing sensations. To compare several models under good conditions, it is therefore important to restore a precise and reproducible setup.

Easy Lig: automatic lateral centering for a consistent setup

The Easy Lig ligature incorporates an automatic lateral reed centering system. It makes placement easier and helps the clarinetist return to a consistent position on the mouthpiece from one reed change to another.

A ligature designed for musical qualities as well

Beyond the simplicity of setup, Easy Lig was developed with special attention paid to musical response. Its operation aims to let the reed vibrate freely, with a quick response, clean and precise detachments and comfortable response across the different registers. These qualities are at the heart of Easy Lig's musical research; the sensations obtained naturally depend on the combination of the mouthpiece, reed and musician.

Compatibility with the cane reeds presented in this guide

All the natural cane reed ranges presented in this article — Vandoren, D'Addario, Gonzalez and Marca — are compatible with the Easy Lig ligature for B-flat clarinet, in the formats suited to this type of mouthpiece.

This indication concerns the natural cane reeds described here. For synthetic or hybrid models, compatibility must be checked separately: Légère European Cut reeds are not compatible with Easy Lig.

Choosing your reed well remains essential, but a ligature that allows you to position it correctly and let it vibrate under good conditions also contributes to playing comfort and precision.

Discover the Easy Lig ligature.

To learn more about the setup process, find our article How to properly position a clarinet reed?

10. Frequently asked questions

What is the best reed brand for clarinet?

There is no universally best brand. Vandoren, D'Addario, Gonzalez and Marca offer different designs meeting varied expectations.

Does a more expensive reed necessarily give a better sound?

No. Price does not guarantee that a reed will suit a musician better. Its compatibility with the mouthpiece and playing preferences is decisive.

Can you change brands without changing strength?

Yes, but strength indications are not directly equivalent between all brands and all ranges.

What if I want to try a synthetic or hybrid reed?

Discover our comparison dedicated to Légère synthetic and Marca UNIC hybrid reeds. These solutions meet different needs from natural cane.

How many reeds should I use alternately?

For cane reeds, having three or four reeds in good condition and rotating them regularly is a good habit.

Conclusion: choose your cane reed according to your mouthpiece and playing style

Vandoren, D'Addario, Gonzalez and Marca each offer several approaches to cane cut. There is no universally best brand: test a suitable strength, compare ranges under the same conditions and listen to your teacher's advice.

A good reed, a suitable mouthpiece and precise positioning are essential for playing comfort. Easy Lig's automatic lateral centering helps restore a reproducible setup during testing.

And you, which reeds do you use?

Do you play with Vandoren, D'Addario, Gonzalez or Marca reeds? Have you recently changed ranges or strength? Share your experience in the comments below: specify, if you wish, your mouthpiece model, the range and strength of your reed, as well as the differences you felt. Your feedback can help other clarinetists make their choice.

Back to blog

Leave a comment